Title

The name of the group is eduGAIN Computer Security Incident Response Team (CSIRT)

Definitions

This document makes use of the Definitions described in the eduGAIN Constitution [eduGAIN-Constitution] and of the following additional ones:

Remove all the defintions already in eduGAIN Constitution.

Purpose and Responsibilities

eduGAIN-CSIRT provides computer security incident response coordination for eduGAIN. It serves as the primary contact point for all security related issues affecting eduGAIN and more specifically for all the security issues affecting multiple entities from different Federations.

The group eduGAIN-CSIRT maintains a communication infrastructure to assure that all the relevant information is received by the relevant entities relevant Federation Operators and Entities security contacts in eduGAIN. That the information is processed and needed response actions are carried out is the responsibility of the entity and the hosting federation(s)the Entity and respective Federation Operator Security Contacts.

Constituency

eduGAIN-CSIRT provides incident response coordination for the entities organized in the federations Entities of members of Identity Federations participating in eduGAIN.

Service Description

Members of eduGAIN-CSIRT provide or assist in providing the following services:

...

services described in section 5 of the [eduGAIN-CSIRT RFC 2350]  document.

Service Level Description

The services described above are provided at least during business hours (9x5 CET/CEST) with 24-hour response, and outside business hours on a best-effort basis.

Composition

Membership

eduGAIN-CSIRT consists of:

• the eduGAIN-CSIRT Security Officer.Senior , that will be nominated by the GEANT project.
  
• At the time of the establishment of the eduGAIN-CSIRT the eduGAIN Participants will be invited to propose members of the eduGAIN-CSIRT. The proposed members must be senior security professionals from IT infrastructures so designated research and education IT infrastructures and it must have previous experience in a security position in the home organization. The proposals will be reviewed for acceptance by the eduGAIN -CSIRT Security Officer.
• An eduGAIN Participant can always propose a new member of the eduGAIN-CSIRT, following the same criteria specified above. The proposal will be reviewed for acceptance by the eduGAIN Security Officer according to the actual needs of the eduGAIN-CSIRT and the eduGAIN Steering Group Chair. The designation process will be based on the principles of fair representation of the federations and the research  and education infrastructures, regional coverage and IT security skills.
• Each member of the eduGAIN-CSIRT will be funded by the respective organization either through the GEANT project, or direct funding.Invited members: GEANT CERT Security Officer. Others?

Chair

The Chair of eduGAIN-CSIRT is the eduGAIN Security Officer.

Duties and responsibilities

The duties and responsibilities of the Chair include:

• Managing team membership.
• Reporting to the the eSG as appropriateScheduling and running eduGAIN-CSIRT meetings and ensuring that minutes are taken and published.
• Ensuring all discussion items end with a decision, action or definite outcome.
• Inviting specialists to attend meetings when required according to the eduGAIN-CSIRT agenda.
• Acting as general point of contact for eduGAIN-CSIRT.
• Ensuring that documents produced are presented for approval and adoption and that once approved these are published and made available.team activity and output is documented, approved when needed, and distributed to the appropriate audience;
• Ensuring that the eduGAIN-CSIRT meets the various demands placed on it to produce and maintain policysecurity policies, security procedure and best practice. This  This will include negotiation with eSG, members of the eduGAIN-CSIRT, and other stakeholders to agree on priorities and timelines, in a manner commensurate with the effort available to the eduGAIN-CSIRT.

• Ensuring that the eduGAIN-CSIRT provides the services and the service level described in 3.2 and 3.3.

The duties and responsibilities of the members include:

• Participating to the Group.the  eduGAIN-CSIRT meetings.
• Following the eduGAIN CSIRT internal procedures.
• Actively contributing to the mission of the eduGAIN-CSIRT.
• Providing expertise and guidance to the best of their knowledge.
• Abiding to the Trusted Introducer Code of Conduct [TI CCoP].
• Respecting TLP restrictions [FIRST TLP] and appropriate confidentiality requirements.
• Providing the services and the service level described in 3.2 and 3.3.Reporting to the the eSG as appropriate.

Term of Office

The Term of Office is unlimited.

Method of Appointment

The eSG appoints the eduGAIN-CSIRT Chair is appointed by the GEANT project.

Operating Procedures

The operation of eduGAIN-CSIRT will obey the eduGAIN Declaration [eduGAIN Declaration] and the eduGAIN Constitution . [eduGAIN Constitution] and follow the procedures approved by the eSG. Any Stakeholder within eduGAIN stakeholder has the right to suggest new policies and procedures: such requests should be submitted to the eduGAIN Security Officer. The decision whether to accept this request  or not request will be discussed within the eduGAIN CSIRT and decision will be recorded in the minutes of the meeting and feedback will be provided to the original requestor.

Communications and Meetings

All the members of the Group eduGAIN-CSIRT must subscribe to the eduGAIN-CSIRT mailing list (edugain-support-sec-team@lists.geant.org)
and should use it as the primary written communication channel. To allow for low latency
communications, the team may community communicate using end-to-end encrypted instant messaging channels
provided all end-points have been pre-authenticated during a face-to-face validation.

The group
deliberations happen at face-to-face meetings, phone/video conferences, or via the group mailing list.
To enable consideration, where practicable, the draft agenda together with reports and documents that relate to the group will be
forwarded to members three working days prior to scheduled meetings.

Accurate minutes will be kept
of each meeting of the group. The minutes of a meeting shall be submitted to group members for
ratification at the next subsequent meeting of the group.

Decision making

Decisions by the group will be made as follows:

• Wherever possible, the Group will arrive at proposed draft recommendations documents and/or advice by clear consensus, as determined by the Chair

•  A voting process will only start if consensus cannot be reached after two consecutive group meetings or if at least one third of voting members of the Group call for a vote

•  A decision is adopted if more than 50% of the voting members present cast their vote for the  proposed decision

•  If the group’s recommendations are adopted by majority vote, minority positions will be recorded and reported

• The group, by majority decision, may refer matters for decision to the Director eduGAIN Steering Group on issues where a consensus cannot be achieved.

Peer Organizations

The eduGAIN-CSIRT shall proactively communicate with recognized peer organizations regarding suspected and confirmed security incidents that could affect such peers. It shall maintain a reference to the operating policies and practices of such peer infrastructures and participate in their processes and the evolution thereof.

External Collaborations

The eduGAIN-CSIRT members can decide to collaborate with external experts or entities for the purpose of assisting in a specific incident response or investigation. The external experts'  contribution will be limited to the scope of the incident and it will last for the time of the investigation and resolution of the incident.

Communication Channels

Related material and references

...

Related material is available on the eduGAIN website at the following location: https://

...

edugain.

...

org/

...

edugain-security/references/

Reporting

eduGAIN-CSIRT provides input about current operational security activities to Federation Operators group and eSG on request.

Authority

eduGAIN-CSIRT is authorized by the eSG to coordinate computer security incident response activities within its Terms of Reference and the applicable security policies. The eSG is the governing body of eduGAIN-CSIRT.

References

[eduGAIN Constitution] https://technical.edugain.

TO BE DISCUSSED:

should we explicitly mention particular actions we would need to take in situations where we would need to take serious actions like suspending participants as a last resort to protect eduGAIN as such

org/doc/eduGAIN-Constitution-v3ter-web.pdf

[eduGAIN-CSIRT RFC2350] https://edugain.org/edugain-security/rfc2350 

[eduGAIN Declaration] https://technical.edugain.org/doc/eduGAIN-Declaration-v2bis-web.pdf

[FIRST TLP] https://www.first.org/tlp

[TI CCoP]https://www.trusted-introducer.org/TI-CCoP.pdf

...